Insurance Law Section
ILS Events Calendar



Insurance Law Section Council Meeting (Houston)

11:00am - 1:30pm at the Law Offices of Gardere Wynne Sewell



20th Annual Insurance Law Institute (Dallas)

Nov. 12-13, 2015 – Cityplace Conference Center, Dallas - Presented by The University of Texas School of Law and The Insurance Law Section of the State Bar of Texas (More)

When is a Breach Not a Breach?
by Tarron L. Gartner

Greene v. Farmers Ins. Exch. and the SCOT’s Continuing Debate over the Material Breach Rule

Co-author: Whitney Warren

Last summer, the Texas Supreme Court’s decision in Greene v. Farmers Ins. Exchange, probably left most of us scratching our heads.  In Greene, the Court reached the surprising conclusion – at odds with the Court’s prior rulings – that the vacancy clause of a Texas homeowners policy is not “breached” by the insured’s failure to occupy the residence premises, because it does not confer an obligation upon the insured to occupy the property, but merely defines the scope of what the policy insures.  Therefore, concluded the Court, neither the anti-technicality statute nor the material-breach rule prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for a loss that occurs while the property is vacant, even if the vacancy did not contribute in any way to the loss. 

Factual Summary

The insured, LaWayne Greene, insured her house through Farmers Insurance Exchange under a Texas Homeowners-A Policy (HOA) form, endorsed by TDI, effective from February 10, 2007 to February 10, 2008. Greene moved out of her residence o...(Continue)

Recent Decisions
Mandamus Will Protect a Privileged Note in Employers' Liabiilty Insurer's Claim File  
In re Texas Health Resources and Trumbull Insurance Company Tx 5-Dallas 8/26/15—
A lawsuit filed by a nurse who contracted Ebola at Presbyterian Hospital has resulted in jurisdictional and discovery disputes regarding employers' liability policy.
District Court Has the Right to Remove an Appriasal Umpire and Appoint a Replacement  
Cantu v. Southern Insurance Company Tx 3-Austin 8/25/15—
Court of Appeals rejects insured's contention that an appraisal award was not binding because the homeowners' insurer did not follow procedures and umpire acted outside his authority.
Court of Appeals Denies Workers' Compensation Insurer's Plea to the Jurisdiction  
American Cas. Co. of Reading, Pa. v. Bushman Tx 4-San Antonio 8/19/15—
A hearing officer's decision on denial of workers' compensation claim does not become final until 15 days after it is forwarded to the claimant's attorney, even if it is timely forwarded to the claimant.
District Court Rules that Underlying Claimant's Counterclaims against Insurer are not an Impermissible Direct Action  
AIX Specialty Insurance Co. v. BBL Investments, Inc. SD Tx 8/18/15—
By naming underlying claimant as a defendant in the first instance, insurer was subject to claimant's counterclaims
Insured's Intentional Misleading of Defendant Insurer Sinks Hail Claim  
De Jongh v State Farm Lloyds Inc. SD Tx 8/17/15—
Statute of limititations is not tolled when insurer is misidentified and harmed by insured's antics
Insurer Fails to Establish Intent to Allocate Settlement Among Settling Parties  
Interstate Fire & Casualty Co. v. Catholic Diocese of El Paso 5th Cir 8/14/15—
Insurer obligated to indemnify insured in full, no obligation to pay attorneys' fees or interest because of waiver of claim
District Court Finds Insured Properly Joined Individual Adjuster in Hail Storm Insurance Dispute  
Glidewell v. Safeco Insurance Co. of Indiana ND Tx 8/13/15—
Insurer failed to meet its burden to show no possibility of recovery against adjuster
Texas Mutual Entitled to Mandamus Relief in Worker's Compensation Dispute  
In re Texas Mutual Insurance Co. Tx 9-Beaumont 8/13/15—
State court lacked jurisdiction prior to exhaustion of administrative dispute resolution process
Court of Appeals grants conditional mandamus relief to workers' compensation insurer  
In Re Texas Mutual Ins. Co. Tx 9-Beaumont 8/13/15—
District court does not have jurisdiction to determine if insurer has waived its right of cancellation until employer has exhausted its administrative remedies.
Fifth Circuit Refuses to Find Sophisticated Insured Exception to Contra Proferentum Rule  
Certain Underwriters at Lloyds London v. Perraud 5th Cir 8/12/15—
Insurer presented no evidence of insured's influence in drafting exclusion; dissent challenges majority's refusal to address threshold ambiguity issue
More Recent Decisions
Section News
Registration is Open for the 20th Annual Insurance Law Institute

Join the Insurance Law Section and UTLaw-CLE at the 20th Annual Insurance Law Institute November 12-13, 2015 at the... (Continued)

More Section News