Insurance Law Section
ILS Events Calendar



Council Meeting

San Antonio. Time and place to be determined.

When is a Breach Not a Breach?
by Tarron L. Gartner

Greene v. Farmers Ins. Exch. and the SCOT’s Continuing Debate over the Material Breach Rule

Co-author: Whitney Warren

Last summer, the Texas Supreme Court’s decision in Greene v. Farmers Ins. Exchange, probably left most of us scratching our heads.  In Greene, the Court reached the surprising conclusion – at odds with the Court’s prior rulings – that the vacancy clause of a Texas homeowners policy is not “breached” by the insured’s failure to occupy the residence premises, because it does not confer an obligation upon the insured to occupy the property, but merely defines the scope of what the policy insures.  Therefore, concluded the Court, neither the anti-technicality statute nor the material-breach rule prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for a loss that occurs while the property is vacant, even if the vacancy did not contribute in any way to the loss. 

Factual Summary

The insured, LaWayne Greene, insured her house through Farmers Insurance Exchange under a Texas Homeowners-A Policy (HOA) form, endorsed by TDI, effective from February 10, 2007 to February 10, 2008. Greene moved out of her residence o...(Continue)

TDI News
TDI Announces Top 10 Insurance Fraud Cases of 2013
More than $10.3 million in insurance fraud was identified in criminal cases referred for prosecution by the TDI Fraud Unit in 2013.
TDI Issues Bulletin Regarding Roofers and Insurance Adjusters
TDI has issued a bulletin to insurance companies, insurance adjusters, and roofers, reminding them of prohibitions related to public insurance adjusters.
Rule Aims to Assist Injured Employees Seeking Lifetime Income Benefits
The Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) is accepting public comment on a rule that will assist injured employees seeking Lifetime Income Benefits in the Texas workers’ compensation system.
Recent Decisions
Fifth Circuit Rules against Factoring Company in Regard to Structured Settlement Deals  
Symetra Life Insurance Co. v. Rapid Settlements Ltd. 5th Cir 12/31/14—
Factoring company utilized sham arbitrations to circumvent Structured Settlement Protection Act
Homeowner's Insurance Carrier not Obligated to Defend Insureds in Conversion Lawsuit  
Drew v. Texas Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co. Tx 5-Dallas 12/31/14—
Insureds' sale of property not an "occurrence" sufficient to trigger coverage
Insurer Prevails on Modified "Your Work" Exclusion  
Oklahoma Surety Company v. Noviello Tx 5-Dallas 12/29/14—
Policy's removal of subcontractor exception to the "your work" exclusion results in no coverage for underlying lawsuit
Insured's Claim for Interior Damage to Home not Covered  
Gulley v. State Farm Lloyds Tx 4-San Antonio 12/23/14—
Insurer's expert testimony properly admitted and constituted sufficient evidence to establish lack of coverage
Insurer Fails to Timely Appeal Rulings, Resulting in Dismissal  
Liberty Insurance Co. v. Cottongame Tx 2-Ft Worth 12/23/14—
Insurer's attempt to appeal separate rulings falls short, as notice to appeal was filed after time to do so had run
Injured Worker Fails to File Timely Lawsuit in Worker's Compensation Dispute  
Morales v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of Connecticut Tx 1-Houston 12/18/14—
Insurer prevails as court dismisses lawsuit for lack of subject matter jurisdiction
"Insured v Insured" Exclusion Inapplicable to Lawsuit; Collateral Estoppel Bars Relitigation of Key Issue  
Primo v. Great American Insurance Co. Tx 14-Houston 12/18/14—
Insured prevails in coverage dispute, but insurer wins argument barring relitgiation of scope of compensation
Court Grants Insurer's Request to Dissolve Temporary Injunction Barring Re-Appraisal  
Safeco Lloyds Insurance Co. v. Barrentine Tx 5-Dallas 12/17/14—
Temporary injunction in Dallas County disrupts status quo set in Bastrop County court allowing for re-appraisal
Insured Prevails against Underinsured Motorist Insurer  
Farmers Texas County Mutual Insurance Co. v. Pagan Tx 14-Houston 12/16/14—
Insurer fails to establish trial court's abuse of discretion in excluding evidence of prior injury
Injured Worker Not Entitled to In-Home Physical Therapy Compensation  
Figari v. Travelers Indemnity Co. of Connecticut Tx 3-Austin 12/16/14—
Worker's compensation insurer prevails in establishing in-home therapy as not medically necessary
More Recent Decisions
Section News
Membership Directory Added to Website

The Insurance Law Section's website now includes a dynamic directory of section members.  The directory allows members to find each other but has also been designed to provide me... (Continued)

More Section News